How To React When a Client Accuses Your Officer of Lying

The Trackforce Team

Trackforce

November 17, 2017 · 9 min read

Featured image for How To React When a Client Accuses Your Officer of Lying

Everyone in the security industry knows what it’s like to be accused of lying. When your company is responsible for the safety of hundreds or thousands of people, situations are bound to arise where someone feels your officers were not doing their jobs correctly. Because of this, security operations managers are often put in the position of needing to prove that their officers are telling the truth.

You might not be able to avoid this unpleasant situation, but you can be prepared to handle accusations in a way that minimizes the problem. To help understand what to do when an issue like this comes up, we spoke to Ryan Sudrick from Invictus Protective Services in Tempe, Arizona, and Jason Jackson from Southwest Security in the Palm Desert area.

Key takeaways

  • Documentation settles disputes.
    Without records, a simple accusation turns into he-said-she-said.
  • Listen first, defend later.
    Acknowledge the complaint, promise an investigation and commit to a follow-up date.
  • Investigate fully.
    Pull reports, check the data and speak with officers, supervisors and dispatchers.
  • Respond with evidence, in person when you can.
    Show the documentation respectfully, or own the problem and explain your corrective action.
  • Proof is easier with the right tools.
    TrackTik captures GPS-verified tours, time-stamped reports and client-visible activity so disputes end quickly.

Have Systems in Place to Track Officer Actions

When you receive a complaint, it’s vital that you’re able to access documentation that proves whether or not the complaint is valid.

“We have a system in place that tracks our officers,” says Ryan Sudrick. “On top of that, dispatch is constantly checking in on officers while they’re on duty.”

“My company runs a 24-hour dispatch center, we use Silvertrac Software for accountability, and we have GPS tracking in all of our vehicles,” says Jason Jackson. “Between these three systems, we can usually prove to our clients if our officers were doing their jobs correctly.”

If you don’t have a system in place for keeping your officers accountable, getting one should be a priority for your organization. Without proper documentation, an accusation which could have been simple to disprove can quickly devolve into a matter of he-said-she-said. Here is how to finally solve the guard accountability question.

Avoid Being Defensive

When a stakeholder calls your company and accuses an officer of underperforming, the first step is to listen to their complaint and let them know that they’re being understood.

“Your job as an operations manager is to reassure them that you do not tolerate whatever it is that the accusation may be, and that you’ll get to the bottom of it. Most importantly, end the phone call by saying you’ll follow up with them,” says Jason Jackson.

Tell the client that you’ll be launching an internal investigation, and provide them with a realistic timeline for when you will get back to them. Jason notes that failing to listen and respond promptly to complaints like these can escalate the situation, and potentially put your contract at risk.

Launch a Full Investigation

The next step in responding to an accusation is to use all the tools at your disposal to understand what really happened. Many times, this is as simple as pulling up reports from the time when the incident was supposed to have occurred, and checking the data for the specific employee or employees involved.

In addition to reading reports and gathering data, it can also be useful to speak to your officers, their supervisors, dispatchers, and any other staff who might have some insight into the situation.

Respond to the Client

Depending on what you uncover during your investigation, you will be responding to the client in one of two ways: either you have evidence that their claim is incorrect, or you have discovered that it was accurate.

If you have the evidence to disprove their claim, you need to deliver this evidence politely and respectfully.

Jason Jackson says that he typically likes to meet with the people in question face-to-face.

“I like to show them the documentation, show them the printouts and reports from Silvertrac. Human nature is that we don’t trust information given to us over the phone. If I’ve got really strong documentation, I’ll schedule a meeting, sit down with that person, and spend fifteen to twenty minutes with them.”

Remember, you’re not trying to throw the truth in people’s faces; you’re trying to neutralize the problem so they don’t escalate the complaint.

If you do discover that your officers were underperforming, it’s important to reassure the accuser that you have processes in place for handling these kinds of situations.

“We basically assure them that we have our own in-house quality control checks…we explain that everyone hires a bad apple here and there, and we explain our disciplinary action plan. Then we give them the option of choosing not to have that guard back at their property,” says Ryan Sudrick.

In addition, show your gratitude for having these issues brought to your attention. If the complaint was valid, these steps will help you recover when you let your client down.

You Don’t Need to Be Perfect

No security company is going to be 100% perfect. Everyone makes mistakes. It’s not about avoiding them, it’s about responding appropriately when an issue does occur.

“The thing that separates good operators from not-so-good operators is spending the money to have proper supervision and proper training,” says Jason Jackson.

Beyond that, following these guidelines for responding to accusations can help you differentiate yourselves from competitors, and keep your business going strong.

The Evidence That Settles Common Accusations

Most accusations fall into a few familiar patterns. Here is the evidence that answers each one:

The accusationEvidence that answers itWhere it comes from
“Your officer was not on site.”Clock-in time, GPS location and checkpoint scansMobile app time and attendance and the guard tour system
“The patrol never happened.”Time-stamped checkpoints and route historyTour and mobile patrol records
“The officer was sleeping or on the phone.”Activity logs, tour progress and dispatcher check-insTour data and dispatch logs
“Nobody reported the incident.”Incident report with time stamps and notification historyIncident reporting records
“The door was left unlocked.”Completed lockup task with a photo and time stampTask and checkpoint records
“The officer was rude.”Officer notes, witness statements and supervisor reviewDaily activity reports and investigation notes

A Complaint Response Timeline

  1. Within the hour: Acknowledge the complaint, thank the client and promise a follow-up time.
  2. Same day: Pull every relevant report, log and GPS record for the time in question.
  3. Within 24 to 48 hours: Talk to the officer, supervisor and dispatcher, and review the evidence together.
  4. Within 2 to 3 days: Meet the client, ideally in person, and share what you found.
  5. Within 30 days: Check in again to confirm the client is satisfied and the issue has not repeated.

Getting these calls right is a skill. Read why most operations managers hate taking customer phone calls for more on handling them well.

Prevent the Next Accusation

  • Make the work visible. Give clients access to activity through the client portal in TrackTik security operations.
  • Send reports before they ask. Regular summaries answer questions before they become complaints.
  • Check in during shifts. Supervisor and dispatcher check-ins create a record and keep officers engaged.
  • Keep reports complete. ReportPro AI helps officers write clear, consistent reports with an audit trail.
  • Invest in supervision and training. As Jason Jackson says, that is what separates good operators from the rest.

How TrackTik Ends He-Said-She-Said

The companies in this article relied on Silvertrac, dispatch and GPS to prove their officers’ work. For security firms today, TrackTik brings all of that into one platform:

  • Verified presence. GPS, geofencing and checkpoint scans confirm where officers were and when.
  • Evidence-backed reports. TrackTik incident reporting adds time-stamped photo, video, audio and GPS evidence to every report.
  • Live oversight. TrackTik guard management gives supervisors real-time visibility into tours, incidents and daily activity reports.
  • Shared truth. Clients can see the same records you do, so disputes are settled with facts.

Book a TrackTik demo to see how quickly you can answer the next accusation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Listen without getting defensive, acknowledge the concern and promise a follow-up by a specific time. Then investigate using reports, GPS data and conversations with the officer, supervisor and dispatcher, and respond with the evidence, ideally in person.

Use time and attendance records, GPS location, checkpoint scans, dispatcher check-ins and time-stamped reports from the shift. The TrackTik security guard tour system records each checkpoint visit with a time stamp.

Thank the client, explain your quality control and disciplinary process, describe the corrective action you are taking and offer to remove the officer from the site if the client prefers. Then follow up to confirm the issue is resolved.

Yes, respectfully. Showing the documentation, ideally in a short face-to-face meeting, is often the fastest way to settle a dispute. Focus on resolving the issue, not on proving the client wrong.

Acknowledge it right away, ideally within the hour, and give a realistic timeline for your investigation. Slow or missing responses can escalate the situation and put the contract at risk.

Make the work visible. Regular reports, a client portal, supervisor check-ins and complete incident documentation answer most questions before they turn into accusations.

TrackTik records verified tours, GPS locations, time-stamped incident reports with evidence and live activity, and lets clients see that activity through a portal. Disputes are settled with facts instead of opinions. Book a TrackTik demo to see it in action.

Related resources

More on proving the work to clients